While on stage at Inman Connect New York, Mauricio Umansky argued that Clear Cooperation stifles competition. Meanwhile, James Dwiggins said the rule puts the customer first.
Source: Inman News
Umansky, Dwiggins clash in heated debate over Clear Cooperation
Published in brad inman, Brokerage, ccp, clear cooperation, Clear Cooperation Policy, compass, Events, exp, eXp Realty, Gary Gold, glenn kelman, hoby hanna, ICNY, ICNY2025, ICNY25, inman connect, Inman Connect New York, James Dwiggins, Leo Pareja, Mauricio Umansky, MLS & Associations, Multiple Listings Service, national association of realtors, new york, nexthome, pocket listings, real estate market, Redfin, robert reffkin, Select and the agency
More from brad inmanMore posts in brad inman »
- Inman is celebrating 30 years of community, and you’re invited
- Companies must ‘get big in order to compete’ with Compass-Anywhere
- In an uncertain market, Inman Connect New York offers solutions
- A compliance expert quizzed ChatGPT. Here’s what it got wrong
- 7 red flags that your real estate business is headed for a wipeout
More from BrokerageMore posts in Brokerage »
- Redfin on 2026: Affordability improves, sales rise only slightly
- Dual licensing is on the rise. Is it the right move for your business?
- Future-proof your digital footprint for 2026 (and beyond)
- Change strategy as the market shifts to win the listings long game
- Listing leverage: How to win the game of securing sellers
More from ccpMore posts in ccp »
- Commission lawsuits? AI? Clear Cooperation? Fuggedaboutit
- Compass agrees to share its exclusive listings, with 2 caveats
- Dwiggins: Zillow understands the consumer better than NAR
- Dwiggins on Compass, Zillow and real estate ‘Armageddon’
- With an eye on future lawsuits, Compass formally repudiates CCP in letter to NAR and MLSs
More from clear cooperationMore posts in clear cooperation »
- The fallout from NAR’s big reversal: Take the Intel Index survey today
- Inman is celebrating 30 years of community, and you’re invited
- The path for Compass-Anywhere: Take the Intel Index survey today
- The MLS isn’t dead yet, but brokers hedge bets with private listings
- Jason Oppenheim respects the Compass deal, but says he’s ‘not happy about it’
More from Clear Cooperation PolicyMore posts in Clear Cooperation Policy »
More from compassMore posts in compass »
- This team is jumping on the private listing platform trend (EXCLUSIVE)
- Real CEO talks growth in hard times — and how everyone loses in real estate ‘wars’
- Shutdown blip, or worrying trend? Agent pipelines thin in November
- In crowded virtual staging category, Collov AI offers ease, affordability: Tech Review
- Zillow’s listing ban hangs in the balance after 4-day hearing
More from EventsMore posts in Events »
More from expMore posts in exp »
More from eXp RealtyMore posts in eXp Realty »
More from Gary GoldMore posts in Gary Gold »
- NAR opts to keep Clear Cooperation but adds a new option
- Robert Reffkin predicts the end of Clear Cooperation in 2025
- Where real estate’s major players stand on Clear Cooperation Policy
- Clear Cooperation takes center stage, faces pressure to change
- Pocket listings are thriving 4 years after NAR sought to end practice
More from glenn kelmanMore posts in glenn kelman »
- Zillow’s listing ban hangs in the balance after 4-day hearing
- Redfin site fluke exposed past users’ data on listing contact forms
- Redfin hits back at Compass, notches victory in Zillow case
- Compass pulls Redfin into its Zillow private listing lawsuit
- Lingering questions, NAR opinion, new lawsuit: Inman Top 5
More from hoby hannaMore posts in hoby hanna »
- Giving back in a time of uncertainty: How real estate leaders are changing lives
- Howard Hanna expands into NYC with purchase of Elegran
- Hoby Hanna: What no one tells you about leading through a merger
- Howard Hanna launches first rebrand in more than 40 years
- Dwiggins on Compass, Zillow and real estate ‘Armageddon’
More from ICNYMore posts in ICNY »
- Innovation takes the stage at Inman Connect New York
- Inman announces the 2025 Inman Connect San Diego Ambassadors
- Want to fall in love with real estate all over again? Here’s how
- Is it you? Call for speakers for Inman Connect San Diego 2025
- Leaders foresee opportunity in wake of antitrust commission suits
More from ICNY2025More posts in ICNY2025 »
- Catch up on all the big commission conversations from Inman Connect
- Leaders foresee opportunity in wake of antitrust commission suits
- ‘If you’re a Realtor, you can’t be a NIMBY’: Joe Rand on affordability
- Catch up on the best of Inman Connect New York: The Download
- Agents need to push past fear when posting online
More from ICNY25More posts in ICNY25 »
- Want to fall in love with real estate all over again? Here’s how
- Is it you? Call for speakers for Inman Connect San Diego 2025
- Catch up on all the big commission conversations from Inman Connect
- Leaders foresee opportunity in wake of antitrust commission suits
- ‘If you’re a Realtor, you can’t be a NIMBY’: Joe Rand on affordability
More from inman connectMore posts in inman connect »
- The fallout from NAR’s big reversal: Take the Intel Index survey today
- Inman is celebrating 30 years of community, and you’re invited
- From Vegas to venture capital: Navigating the uncertain path of the proptech founder
- Innovation takes the stage at Inman Connect New York
- The path for Compass-Anywhere: Take the Intel Index survey today
More from Inman Connect New YorkMore posts in Inman Connect New York »
More from James DwigginsMore posts in James Dwiggins »
- How this agent-turned-coach went from no social media to 10M monthly organic views
- After failed NAR vote, brokerages beef up referral disclosures
- From near collapse to $5B in sales: The big switch this broker made
- How this team leader built a 90% repeat and referral business
- Kris Lindahl on why unapologetic authenticity is your only sustainable marketing plan
More from Leo ParejaMore posts in Leo Pareja »
- After failed NAR vote, brokerages beef up referral disclosures
- Inman is celebrating 30 years of community, and you’re invited
- EXp digs at Compass during Q3 earnings as agent retention soars
- In an uncertain market, Inman Connect New York offers solutions
- ‘Divine’ timing brings $80M Texas broker to eXp Realty
More from Mauricio UmanskyMore posts in Mauricio Umansky »
- Why 2026 will reward those who plan with precision, not emotion: Mauricio Umansky
- American Real Estate Association hires Mary-Frances Coleman as inaugural executive director
- Mauricio Umansky on how to survive Compass-Anywhere
- The Compass-Anywhere merger: When elite meets scale, what happens to value propositions?
- Here’s why indies are stoked about the Compass-Anywhere deal
More from MLS & AssociationsMore posts in MLS & Associations »
- California Association of Realtors leans into referral fee transparency
- Ex-CEO charged with grand theft; local Realtor association left ‘all but broke’
- NAR’s new consumer profile shows agents how to thrive in 2026
- NAR NXT: The Download on last week’s trends, tensions, takeaways
- Dispatches from NAR NXT as real estate grapples with AI
More from national association of realtorsMore posts in national association of realtors »
More from new yorkMore posts in new york »
- Dual licensing is on the rise. Is it the right move for your business?
- Future-proof your digital footprint for 2026 (and beyond)
- Delistings and discounts jump as holiday season approaches
- ‘More persistent headwinds’ plague housing market as prices barely budge
- What saved my life — and why our industry must choose compassion over judgment
More from nexthomeMore posts in nexthome »
- How this agent-turned-coach went from no social media to 10M monthly organic views
- After failed NAR vote, brokerages beef up referral disclosures
- From near collapse to $5B in sales: The big switch this broker made
- Zillow’s listing ban hangs in the balance after 4-day hearing
- How this team leader built a 90% repeat and referral business
More from pocket listingsMore posts in pocket listings »
- Former Coldwell Banker CEO on affordability and ‘purple’ policies
- Engel & Völkers’ CEO: ‘We’re focused on culture over indiscriminate scale’
- NAR fires back at Mauricio Umansky’s PLS in new legal filing
- Brad Inman to agents: AI will eliminate the great Clear Cooperation debate
- Competition, discretion drive lux agents to embrace private listings
More from real estate marketMore posts in real estate market »
- Brokers are losing to ChatGPT. Here are 10 new AI rules of the road
- The inventory surge is sputtering. See how your market stacks up
- Brandi Marshall on ‘Selling the OC’ stardom, feuds and a brutal real estate market
- ‘Real estate is the sacrificial lamb of high interest rates’: Jason Oppenheim rants on the Fed
- Finish 2025 strong by checking these 10 to-dos off your list
More from RedfinMore posts in Redfin »
- Redfin on 2026: Affordability improves, sales rise only slightly
- Bayview merger positions Guild Mortgage for refinancing boom
- Zillow reverses course and removes climate data from listings
- Delistings and discounts jump as holiday season approaches
- The IDX lie agents still believe: 5 common misconceptions about real estate websites
More from robert reffkinMore posts in robert reffkin »
- Zillow’s listing ban hangs in the balance after 4-day hearing
- Will Anywhere merger launch M&A arms race? It’s not yet clear: Intel
- Inman is celebrating 30 years of community, and you’re invited
- Zillow defends private listing rule, criticizes Compass in new filing
- Despite unease, Compass poised to retain most Anywhere agents
More from SelectMore posts in Select »
- This team is jumping on the private listing platform trend (EXCLUSIVE)
- Redfin on 2026: Affordability improves, sales rise only slightly
- Dual licensing is on the rise. Is it the right move for your business?
- Future-proof your digital footprint for 2026 (and beyond)
- Change strategy as the market shifts to win the listings long game
More from the agencyMore posts in the agency »
- The most iconic house in Los Angeles is now for sale
- Why 2026 will reward those who plan with precision, not emotion: Mauricio Umansky
- Luxury’s next phase: What the 2026 buyer really wants
- American Real Estate Association hires Mary-Frances Coleman as inaugural executive director
- Jason Oppenheim: ‘Epic’ real estate + big drama makes new ‘Selling the OC’ season the best yet
Be First to Comment